I like this idea, simple and no way to get around it really.
But I agree with MasterP on his point that even bad servers should not be delisted.
But what if people just go around joining and d/c just to be jerks?
Perhaps there should also be a way to rate the players themselves.
And on the AFK kicker, it should only affect people who aren’t regulars on the server.
That’s how the [PbP] server works and it’s quite nice.