Brian informed me about this before posting. Anytime an admin takes action against another admin and I find out it’s going to end up being public so best you both get your sides of the story out before I take action.
The person in question was on the residential network of Duke University.
My biggest problem with this whole situation was why did it matter that he had a low ping? We get people in the server with low pings all the time and as an admin it is not within your right to demand that a player tell you where he lives. It shouldn’t matter. With our rate enforcement settings it’s practically impossible for someone to change rates to artificially look that low and even if they could it would show as a ping of 1 or 2, not 5-10.
I’m putting this issue on hold until I can sort everything out.