I *shock* actually agree with Liam; we need to add a points system like CSS has.
Here is my proposition for maps; keep in mind these are mainly the most played maps on Jiggly’s Fun House servers, which is one of the highest ranked TF2 servers out there (Jiggly’s #1 AVERAGED 20.4 ppl last week… they are a 24 man server)
ctf_turbine_v3
ctf_mach4
cp_warpath
cp_dustbowl
cp_gravelpit
ctf_2fort
cp_labor
cp_well
cp_castle3
Not really in that order but I think that would be a good start for maps (even though I hate 2fort…)